Support the channel with a coin! • For viewers from Russia — https://boosty.to/mikitkosynalexeev • Not from Russia — / mikitkosynalexeev Abstract: Nizhny Novgorod teacher Tatyana Hartman, author of the channel "Uchilka vs TV", is now at the zenith of her fame: she was invited to work at Mayak radio, she was offered to teach classes to officials, she regularly appears on TV, the media write about her, top bloggers with an audience of millions advertise her. But is she worthy of such attention? She, who constantly makes factual errors, promotes some kind of outdated taste and amateurism, demonstrates double standards, does not skimp on empty accusations! Is it really that there is no more worthy connoisseur of the Russian word in our country? For six years of running the channel, I have never filmed reviews of other bloggers. And I never even thought that I would ever do this. But I have seen for a year now how "Uchilka" is gaining popularity, everyone only admires it - although it needs the harshest criticism! Fight prescriptivism! In turn, I will say that the goal of the video is not to offend Tatyana (although she once insulted my channel for no reason), but to publicly criticize her activities and draw public attention to current issues in linguistics. I will be a hundred times glad if Tatyana responds to my criticism and admits her MISTAKES - which she constantly encourages people to do herself. UPD: a response has followed. See commentary — • "TEACHER" Tatyana Hartman — DEVASTATIVING... Contents: 00:00 Introduction 02:54 Tatyana's mistakes and distortions 02:54 zero and zero 03:29 to accustom and to accustom 03:54 in several hundred 05:15 different linguistic schools: doshch' and dozhd' 06:17 to eat 07:01 to come and to come 08:55 Ё in words with the root "жен-" 11:13 прикрепéпим and прицепи́м 12:43 погрýзить и погрáться 13:18 What content would I advise Tatyana to make 14:06 "Mistakes" for which Tatyana reproaches others, but which she makes in her own speech. And how she explains them differently in herself and in others. 16:40 Tatyana reproaches others for their lack of insight, but she herself does not notice obvious things. Analysis of the case with my video. 19:09 Tatyana's low level of theoretical knowledge of language 20:40 Analysis of the statement about the change in stress "convicted - deposed" in her book 22:25 The real reasons for this change 23:50 "Speech Nuance" - my program about the literary norm 25:15 Criticism of the general approach. What is prescriptivism and why does it contradict the modern scientific view of language 26:30 The concepts that Tatyana speculates on: “error” and “rule”, “correctly” - and how this leads to a false understanding of language 29:30 Tatyana denies people linguistic subjectivity, and language, in her opinion, “fluctuates along with the party line” 30:25 Tatyana commits forgery 31:03 Some of Tatyana’s instructions run counter to common sense 33:30 The inconsistency of some instructions 34:07 What the average person notices from changes in the language and what he considers “illiterate” 35:56 How celebrities react to Tatyana’s analyses 37:15 Responses to some objections 38:12 Words in defense of Tatyana My other materials: • Playlist “Speech nuance” - • SPEECH NUANCE [“Mistakes” in speech, their and... Video about “Netu”, “Zvonit”, “Kushat”, “Ikhniy” — also here. • Conversation #3. Norms of the Russian language — what is REALLY behind them? — • Norms of the Russian language — what is st... (I warn you, there is a long humorous piece at the beginning lasting 12 minutes. Skip to the 12th minute immediately. It was three years ago. Back then I was filming strange videos lasting an hour and a half...) • Conversation #4. Why is Russian stress so difficult? — • Why is Russian stress so difficult? • OLD MOSCOW PRONUNCIATION and what is left of it — • OLD MOSCOW PRONUNCIATION and what is left of... See also: • Video of Uchitelka with me — • “Uchitelka vs TV”: ERRORS IN VERBS! • "Proofreader vs. Teacher" from the channel "S/PRAVKA" — • PROOFREADER vs. TEACHER • Zaliznyak A. A. An episode from the history of Russian stress — • A. A. Zaliznyak: An episode from the history of Rus... • Marginal continues to destroy Teacher (interview with Pushnoy) — • Marginal continues to destroy Teacher... Subscribe to our other resources! • Telegram main — https://t.me/chtenye_tg • VK — https://vk.com/chtenye_vk • Instagram — / mikitko_syn_alexeev • Telegram with photos — https://t.me/mikitko_syn_alexeev • Website — https://mikitko.ru